Transfer nonsense, Twitter and the rest...
This social media culture is wonderful.
Twitter, for instance, brings friends closer, it's immediate, settles differences and it throws new people together.
And can be amazingly funny when people start to filter home from nights out.
As far as the transfer circus and the media is concerned, we're not always the easiest of bedfellows.
Take Eiji Kawashima. The Japanese goalkeeper is a friend of mine. Not in reality - but I do follow him on Twitter.
Of course, this isn't the real Lierse goalkeeper, but a Twitter account set-up by someone to parody the real Kawashima, who for weeks has been telling everyone he will be joining Albion.
He was adamant that his signing was imminent.
The Baggies, meanwhile, denied this when first put to them. Then they just laughed. These days it simply irritates them - especially when the real Kawashima issues an ultimatum telling the Baggies to decide whether they want him or not.
Sorry, Eiji, they don't.
Such is the power of social media that a ridiculous story about Peter Odemwingie failing to agree terms with Arsenal - based on two 'friends' of his - was run by a Nigerian website.
Not a usual news source, just one which anyone of any age could set up in their bedroom and portray as a reputable provider of news.
Trouble is that people get sucked in. They see the reports on NewsNow and assume it might, just might, be true.
Such was the power of this report that Albion moved to issue a statement denying it all.
And who can blame them, not least when a UK-based agent is also repeating the false rumour on national radio to millions of listeners. As it happens Albion and Arsenal have had no discussions over Odemwingie, let alone got to a stage where he is quibbling over personal terms.
Arsenal might yet want Odemwingie. But they've done little about it so far.
Mulumbu, subject of a successful £5.5million bid from Fiorentina? No, he isn't. Nor has he been.
That's not to say he won't be one day in the future, but that's guesswork. Which is where a lot of this fuels social media panic, be it on Twitter or on Facebook.
A couple of websites report it in Italy and then it gets picked up and reported as news by the website branch of a national radio station - this much-listened-to radio station employ their own Midlands' reporters, who would have swiftly put their own web colleagues straight had their opinion been sought.
And that is the trouble these days. People are in such a rush to break stories that diligence no longer applies. Nobody bothers checking with clubs to see if a story is true. They might check with an agent to see if it's true - in 11 years of working in football I've come across about a dozen agents I really trust - but even then they might not bother.
Social media has not so much changed the way we work, it's shredded the rule book too.
The growth of Internet and, more so, Twitter and Facebook leads to frenzied excitement and fevered panic.
It's also fueled incorrect assumptions about my own job.
It was brought to my attention that one message-board poster made a reference to myself and another local newspaper being out of loop, implying we were only getting stories from the club. That's completely wide-of-the-mark. Tripe. If only I could get paid for such a relaxed lifestyle.
The official websites of many, if not all, clubs churn out quotes from press conferences and interviews. Not always, but probably 90 per cent of the time, it's the journalists who drive the questions which will appear on your club's official website. Furthermore, if I or any journalist relied on club information as a sole source for our news then we wouldn't last 10 minutes in the job, let alone 10 years or longer. We're simply more exposed now because others are willing to run stories without any checks.
In this climate of frenzied transfer activity - eight days BEFORE the window opens - it's the local media who have to mop up the mess of others, all in the name of providing accurate news. The growth of social media, the expansion of websites who claim to carry the 'latest news' - it's immediate, people demand news.
Let's not forget that newspaper journalists are still working for print publications first and foremost. Some of us will sit on information for the sake of our newspaper deadlines - hoping that the story doesn't break elsewhere.
And to get exclusives on every story would take some doing given the immediacy of news services who can report something (and then forget they ever reported it) - such as the TV station who claimed David Vaughan had already decided to join Albion. I can only presume Vaughan must have posted his reply to Albion via carrier-pigeon as they're still waiting for his decision. Funnily enough, this same TV station have not mentioned Vaughan since. Never wrong for long, eh...
In fact Vaughan wasn't due to deliver his answer until after returning from his holiday. Again, a few phone calls to the right people would have provided this answer.
Boateng, he was never close to joining Albion. Carson, he's still an Albion player.
Again, it's about sorting out the truth from the non-truths, half-truths or the not-yet-truths.
However, what I can do - as do my Birmingham Mail colleagues - is run stories which I know can be stood up, by several sources. Which is why my colleague Mat was able to run, with some confidence, an exclusive that Alex McLeish was wanted by Villa a full week before it happened. And if that means knocking down a rumour which isn't true, and we know isn't true, then we will do so. Every day if necessary. Sometimes we can slip up. But it won't be through negligence.
Some of us still are in the news business, not in the market for 'Internet hits' or 'website traffic'.
Others can fly the kites and get you excited or panicked about transfers which might or might not happen. More than 60 names have linked with Albion since the end of the last season - I have a list of them. So far two have signed. A few are potential targets.
These websites and social media networks have a place in society. And many fans love the speculation during the lull which is bandied around via various branches. But they can have a negative side too.
In the meantime, I'm off to find out what @general_krulak (he is real isn't he?) has been getting up to over in the not-so-real world.




Chris you state that there are still eight days before the transfer window opens. The transfer window opened as soon as the season finished (Premier League rules Section M). Otherwise how could Phil Jones transfer to Man Utd have taken place.
......."Carson, he's still an Albion player.".......
Errrm, no he isn't....
At the time you were writing this blog, Carson was already in Turkey preparing for talks and a look around the facilities at Bursaspor. Today he is having a medical prior to signing. Surely the local specialist journo should have been aware of this!
That's the problem Chris, as a Baggies specific journo writing for the main local paper, you seem to be too far off the ball compared to other national journo's who don't(?) have local contacts and knowledge.
Internet and the incredible 24 hr media availability certainly can't make your job any easier, but perhaps you need to accept that there are club insiders who now provide info to journo's other than BM journo's as was the situation in past times.
The information world has moved on Chris, but it seems that some local journo's have their head in the sand in believing that they are stil considered first choice by those who disclose information from within the local clubs. National media has a much bigger local sway than ever before, and until the local journo's can accept that, they won't, imo, get back to being the main source of information for local supporters.
Hi Anonymous
Actually Scott Carson hasn't signed for the Turkish club (and he certainly was an Albion player at the time I wrote the piece - check the date).
I deal in fact, I don't concern myself in speculation.
Hi Anonymous (10.37am)
The transfer window opens on July 1. Deals can be arranged beforehand, but don't get signed off until this date.
Thanks
Widespread gossip on the internet, causing local journalists to write articles in an effort to justify their jobs.
This will all end in tears, just like Albion appointing Hodgson.
Mark, from Manchester.
Chris, answer me this. Do you not think it is a bit unprofessional to respond in such a way to the anonymous commenter? I was bought up in a world where customer is always right and your tone and response implicate your morals rest elsewhere.
Face facts Chris, your articles and blogs are a bit egotistical and wrapped in self importance. You don't even break a story before the express and dingle let alone the national media.
When i'm failing in my profession, i tend to get out of bed earlier, i think you could learn alot by doing the same.
Hi Charlo_Baggie
Fair point re my message, but I happen to know who it is and know their agenda...
And I fail to see why I should be polite to someone discrediting me, when they're not even willing to post under a real name. It's easy to be a keyboard warrior behind a pseudonym.
Regarding 'breaking stories' (Or not), is that really the point of what I'm trying to do? I'm here to provide readers with factual news. I can think of certain websites who 'break' news several times a day - 99 per cent of it proves correct. People look towards local newspapers to give them fact and, when necessary, comment about their club. That might mean occasional 'egotistical' comment pieces but probably nowhere near as severe as comments you'll find over on message board communities throughout the country.
I've broken enough stories, as have the other newspapers you mention. However, the days of in exclusivity in print media are fading, not least when there are so many sources of news and - unlike the Birmingham Mail and other newspapers - are not bound by printing deadlines. Red top nationals are your best port of call for transfer gossip. Some of this might be true, more of it will be speculation (probably fed by a desperate agent trying to drum up interest for his player).
Strange as it might seem in this modern era, my work is still prioritised towards print deadlines - hence at the mercy of those deadlines and the increasingly futile hope that the story I'm sitting on doesn't break elsewhere.
Thanks for your observations about getting out of bed earlier...I shall reset my alarm.
Chris is the most informed and approachable journalist I know. He "gets it' re twitter and the on line community. Follow him if you want to stay on the ball and have a laugh. Oh, and he is Polish but onlu when England are losing ;-)
Charlo _Baggie
Apologies - I did
Reference: I can think of certain websites who 'break' news several times a day - 99 per cent of it proves correct.
....
I did in fact mean 'incorrect'
Chris, Keep up the fantastic work mate. Seriously ignore the "haters". You do a fantastic job reporting on West Bromwich Albion.
Dave
Football fans look to their local papers to communicate fact and trust them to do that. There is so much trash written on the net, whilst nationals have the luxury of not having to maintain relationships with the clubs that local journos do. I think we are lucky at the local football journo's we have in Brum, I particularly rate Chris and his Albion coverage, cheers from Halfords Lane.
Good article. Valid points made about people not doing the leg work. So many times you see things in the press that you know have just been nicked from Twitter.
Some of us know which journalists deserve our respect and trust and Chris is definitely one of them.
That's just, like, you're opinion, man.
Good article, so 'Flat Earth News' applies to football too, journalists pressured into posting unsubstantiated stories in order to meet deadlines and fill column inches under pressure from their editors. Glad that you are doing a good job.
I think those who are being critical need to examine the detail of Chris's work and compare it to his peers. You only have to look at the E&S- and this is certainly no slight on Steve Madeley, whose articles and paper-space I spend a lot of time reading- to know that Chris's articles hit the web a lot sooner (E&S's tend to go up at certain times of the day). He allows himself to be accessible to his target market at all hours of the day through Twitter and online feeds. If you send him a question, he'll generally respond almost immediately. I can't think of any other journalists that do this to such an extent (although admittedly I don't work in media).
Of the articles Chris does publish, I can't ever recall one being proved false. The speculation generated elsewhere is given as such; the facts or knowledge is generally proved correct.
Egotistical and wrapped in self-importance? Yes I can see how it can be perceived as such, but how does a writer who has access to knowledge demanded by tens of thousands convey it modestly?? You're almost asking him to apologise for having it. If he responds to a thousand tweets in a conversational and friendly manner, he'll undoubtedly end up with a thousand more tweets. Until any of us have spent a day in Chris's job, I imagine it's difficult for any of us to tell him to do it better.
Chris- this isn't intended as a sycophantic response, but you do seem to have taken some of the above quite personally. I'm sure you're already more than aware that you'll never please everyone, but I imagine there are far more that appreciate your work out there than don't.
Give me one true story over fifty fake stories anytime.
Personally I think the whole social media world has caused so much stink.. Yes people say it connects people and brings them together. Look on the flip side to this. It create's issue's with peoples lives other than football, like relationships and loosing jobs over small remarks... It's stupid when I thought this country was all about freedom of speech. It's a load of rubbish if you ask me. If your life is in the media you only have to say one word out of context and people jump on the hate train and want to stone you to death. Why are people in this world so fickle!!.. They clearly don't understand the term nobody's perfect!.. It's the truth everyone gets stressed out and makes mistakes it's only human.. we all get annoyed with life! So why can't we be allowed to be harsh, swear rant or release whatever stresses we have? Basically do what we want. People shouldn't feel as if they are under control because they are falsifying who they really are. Chris ignore the haters just keep doing your job mate. I'm a Baggie through and through... I've read stories and hear word of mouth blah blah blah!. I don't listen I only believe it when it's happened and real. Your stories have truth so hense my alliance to your cause!
Final point: Social media has made the world paranoid and pointing the finger, so don't be sucked into believing everything you read!..
Thanks.
Personally I think the whole social media world has caused so much stink.. Yes people say it connects people and brings them together. Look on the flip side to this. It create's issue's with peoples lives other than football, like relationships and loosing jobs over small remarks... It's stupid when I thought this country was all about freedom of speech. It's a load of rubbish if you ask me. If your life is in the media you only have to say one word out of context and people jump on the hate train and want to stone you to death. Why are people in this world so fickle!!.. They clearly don't understand the term nobody's perfect!.. It's the truth everyone gets stressed out and makes mistakes it's only human.. we all get annoyed with life! So why can't we be allowed to be harsh, swear rant or release whatever stresses we have? Basically do what we want. People shouldn't feel as if they are under control because they are falsifying who they really are. Chris ignore the haters just keep doing your job mate. I'm a Baggie through and through... I've read stories and hear word of mouth blah blah blah!. I don't listen I only believe it when it's happened and real. Your stories have truth so hense my alliance to your cause!
Final point: Social media has made the world paranoid and pointing the finger, so don't be sucked into believing everything you read!..
Thanks.
Linked here by the Guardian.
I appreciate the job Journos like you do in separating fact from fiction. It can be difficult finding relevant, factual news about your team, especially regarding transfers. And doesn't help when you have certain websites (CaughtOffside?) linking players and clubs at random.
**Breaking News** Carson has signed for Bursaspor!!
Nice article Chris. "Sigh" why can't we have someone like you write about Arsenal, iso of having to read a lot of negative spin, rumours and gossip every day.
An earlier poster requested that you get out of bed a bit earlier..... can I request that you do not go to bed at all, with the time difference between there and here in Australia, I would be getting the "info" from you more in time with my waking hours, thanks again
Hi Chris,
I am contacting you on behalf on an online bookmaker who would like to advertise on this blog. If you do have advertising price list and would like to discuss this opportunity further please contact me on the above email address.
As well as providing editorial opportunities for your blog with betting markets, we can also discuss an affiliate programme, subject to a few criteria. I'm sure you understand the model but with a simple programme, we can agree a commission share for every reader that opens an account with. We would require you to share certain information with us but we hope this wouldn't be a problem due to the commercial benefit.