Roberto thoughts
FOR Albion, see West Ham United.
The Baggies' decision to appoint Roberto Di Matteo may have prompted surprise but scratch beneath the surface if you can. It's no shock, really.
You only have to look at the West Ham model to see what Jeremy Peace had in mind. Gianfranco Zola's success at Upton Park has no doubt been part of the inspiration behind Albion's move.
A young Italian, with little experience of managing, working at a club where he will work alongside a sporting and technical director...sounds familiar, just like West Ham (and exactly why Alan Curbishley was never a consideration). Di Matteo isn't even a manager - he's a head coach.
If it works as well as it has in east London then it'll be an inspired decision.
And you can't blame Peace for taking the gamble.
Di Matteo, born in Switzerland to Italian parents, may lack the experience of a Dave Jones, the fans' adulation of a Derek McInnes or the coaching know-how of an Alan Irvine.
But he will stick Albion back on the radar. Let us not forget that this is a man who managed to transform the loathsome MK Dons into a semi-fashionable club.
And Albion's decision to overlook other candidates may not be a bad thing. Dave Jones never really convinced anyone that his heart was set on leaving Cardiff. McInnes, like Di Matteo, remains inexperienced. A bad season would have tarnished the image of McInnes, who remains a hero. His time may yet come sometime in the future. Darren Ferguson was too expensive and Adie Boothroyd would have triggered a deluge of season ticket books being returned - if you go with the reaction to a story about his possible interest in the job.
Irvine was highly spoken of but didn't convince Albion, which left Di Matteo, although we must not necessarily assume that he was the last man standing.
He impressed during his interview. He 'blew our socks off' was how one source put it. Those close to the MK Dons club claim he's thoughtful and his sides like to attack. He seems to be an attacking 4-5-1 man, whose teams include a holding midfielder and a couple of wide men. Now where have we seen that recently? It's not necessarily all about passing, attacking play. Unlike Tony Mowbray he appreciates the times where games need to be killed off, rather than opened out.
Fans won't see a ranter on the touchline. When the MK Dons were involved in their play-off semi-final shoot out defeat to Scunthorpe, the 39-year-old was calm, controlled. There were few outbursts of emotion.
The very name itself - that of a man who became a hero at Chelsea, won 34 Italian caps, trophies in Italy and scored in two English FA Cup finals - ensures a spot of kudos for Albion. He was forced to retire at 31 due to a leg injury and turned his attention to coaching.
As recently as three weeks ago he was shortlisted for a job at Swiss club and Europa League qualifiers Basel, only to be denied because he had yet to acquire the remaining coaching badge needed for European competition, which he's currently working towards.
It is a step into the unknown for Albion. It's a gamble which could backfire and, if it does, then inevitable questions will be asked of the chairman for his decision to appoint Di Matteo.
But those are for another day and may never even get asked.
He's inexperienced, no doubt, but then so was Roy Keane when he took Sunderland up. And Di Matteo already has the players at Albion to work towards a similar goal.
His first task will be to restore a winning mentality.
Signing players and convincing some of the current squad to stay might just have got a little easier given the personality involved. And you suspect his contacts book won't be too bad either.
Think about this before you pass judgement - it's not necessarily a bad appointment.
Albion's profile is back on the rise and without a ball being kicked.
Older/Newer
« Have I missed much? Apparently not... | Footballer fever, back again »



Got to admit I'm sceptical about this. Yes there have been examples recently of inexperienced managers delivering results but those had a board that backed them with money, something ours is unlikely to do. Would've preferred someone with experience of the Premiership because as we saw last season it makes a big difference, but at least RDM's preferred playing style means we don't need a massive squad overhaul.
Good luck to him and I will back him during his tenure - I support Albion, end of. I just hope that your optimism is founded Chris and he proves Mr Negative here wrong.
Head coach and director of football don't work in this country. Clearly a cheap option that allows Peace to carry on his merry way buying players ie Cox and continue the cycle of Premier League failure. This is the point where Albion start to really nosedive for me.
Mark,
I can see your point regarding Cox - but, and I'd be critical of this if I thought otherwise, I honestly believe Albion were pitching their interest for a player knowing that the window opens today. I honestly don't think they would hoist an unwanted player on the new manager (or head coach if you prefer!). But because there is likely to be a lot of interest in him, I think it was a case of Albion ensuring that they don't miss out on someone who the scouting network identified as being capable of doing a job at this level. I may be wrong and the cynic in me thought the same as you but I honestly felt this was a gesture of intent by albion to ensure they don't miss out on a player.
Chris
I cannot see why a Head coach and director do not work. If you scratch beneath the surface , most clubs may well have that set up in any case. West Ham isn't a bad example to hold up either, despite the obvious parallel.
Would we want to see another summer of squandering cash a la Robson? I would also imagine any player is vetoed, if RDM wouldn't pick them. Isn't that why clubs have people in on trial al la Koren?
I think it is an inspired choice, and one I am very excited about. There shouldn't be a huge change in the squad, as he will play a passing game, and I would imagine he will be able to tactically close games down. He's played under some excellent managers in his time and he must have some great contacts in the game. He took MK Dons (just promoted remember) to the play-offs, and he has cut his teeth at a lower level. He is young and hungry too.
A much better prospect than a has-been IMO.
PS - as for Cox, he's highly rated (a lot of interest in him surely including Mowbray) and RDM must surely know a thing or two about him already from last season.
I would imagine any move for Cox would be vetoed, by RDM, and at least Albion have had the offer accepted.....we are now in the driving seat for a player with a lot of potential.
Why can't people be optimistic, or at least open minded? I am not Peace fan, but I think Albion are largely going in the right direction with this appointment and the way business is conducted.
I'm cautious but optimistic about this appointment. It strikes me as a bold move by Mr Peace. Robert Di Matteo is media savvy and will raise the profile of West Bromwich Albion. Was this a bearing on Mr Peace's decision?
I hope he has a successful period here and can lead us back to the Premiership. My only worry is that i have heard some negative feedback about his style of football. I've only watched them on a couple of occasions and they played some lovely football allied with a strong defence. Sounds like the perfect match.
Chris have you watched much of MK Dons and what is your personal view of his style of football?
Also what will happen to Dan Harris? Now that Ade Mafe has come in as fitness coach?
I hope Appelton is named first team coach or given a larger repsonsibility so he decides to stay with us rather then seek pastures new.
I'm hopeful he grants the signings of Mulumbu, Menseguez and Cox. Is a Press Conference due to take place? I've just read some quotes attributed to Di Matteo on the OS. I hope we are planning on unveiling him, maybe with Simon Cox
Thanks
Why does your new 'head coach/Jeremy yes man' look like a cross between Fox Mulder and an alien? Discuss