http://blogs.birminghammail.net/westbromwichalbion/

Not great is it?

By Chris Lepkowski on Feb 24, 09 12:31 PM

I took a call at the Albion training ground this morning from the Everton press officer.

And frankly he left me stuck for words.

He wanted me to answer some question about the Baggies, including, among others, to assess Albion's season.

"Are Albion under-achieving or over-achieving?" he asked.

Er...well, yeah...I'm don't..know what, well...

Help.

Back in June I listened to Tony Mowbray explain to myself and a colleague how he wouldn't need to spend much on new players, that Albion played the right kind of football and how they were capable of being away from the relegation zone. He talked himself into trouble in the space of that conversation. Quotes were printed, expectations were levered up.

'Survival', he told us, 'was not deemed as success'.

So here we are. Albion are bottom and have been for a while. Okay, only four points from survival, but in the last two games they've given the impression of trying free-wheel up a fairly steep slope. They look flat and have mislaid the 'Premier League guide to survival'. Mowbray was downbeat when I saw him this morning and his recent demeanour has hardly been of the tub-thumping variety. If I'm noticing that, if fans are getting that impression...then what are the players seeing?

We all know Albion have the lowest wage bill and Mowbray now accepts that he got it wrong in terms of signings - experienced heads were needed and money is actually quite helpful in the Premier League.

This isn't a bad thing. It means he's learning. He is after all, the Premier League's least experienced manager and still young.

The signings have been a mixed bag. Olsson, Morrison, Teixeira and Miller look bargains considering the amount paid for them. But then there's Borja Valero. Four point seven million isn't a lot when it comes to football spending but for a club like Albion it's money they can't afford to waste. Dare I say another £1million would have brought in that defensive midfielder Albion were wanting for most of the season? Borja, as talented as he is, is simply the right player at the wrong club. Possibly even in the wrong country. He looks too light-weight and lately his passing has become, how can I put this, almost Chaplow-esque. He is not the impact player who can make a difference in a struggling side.

So are Albion under-achieving or punching above their weight? They're not far from Stoke, who have invested more on wages for new players, but Hull, even with their recent poor form, have given themselves a platform for survival. Yet Albion are several points better off than Fulham were at this stage last season. And, let's be honest, wage bills do tend to be reflected by League tables. If someone had told you Albion would be four points from safety during the last week of February you'd have probably taken it.

So what of Mowbray? I was told by radio reporters on Sunday that the calls for his head were intensifying. That's never a good sign.

It's my view that change would not help anyone at this stage. Sometimes you need change but not now. For instance Gary Megson's time was most definitely up and had been for months before he left. Only a Jermain Defoe miss at West Ham, when they were 3-0 up, kept him in a job for another 12 months or so. He was that close so many times. Worst of all, he knew it and it was reflected by his demeanour.
Bryan Robson too was always treading a fine line, especially during his final weeks.
Mowbray isn't at that stage by any stretch of the imagination.

And he wouldn't be the first manager to have tried and failed to have kept Albion up. You can only achieve what you can on limited resources. Until Jeremy Peace is able to attract major investment then that's how it'll be - the Albion chairman has already shown that it's the only way the club can move forward. While his name is above the door at the Hawthorns, then Albion will be run on a prudent basis. Any manager will have to like and lump that.

Unlike his two immediate predecessors, Mowbray has a long-term plan for Albion. His signings, as young and raw as some of them are, all have potential. Some will get better. Some will peak at Championship level, with this campaign being the high point of their climb, others will go on to be successful, most probably at other clubs. Mowbray was half-right in saying he needed a few experienced heads around the club. To keep Albion up, yes. But not for the long-term. Robson, for instance, brought in too many quality players who were on the wane or way past their best. In some cases they simply came for a final pay day. The under-current of bitterness and cynicism among Robson's squad of 2006-07 was frightening. Mowbray's greatest achievement in many ways was filleting that squad and rebuilding it into one which took the club up as title winners in what is regarded by footballing folk as the hardest division to win promotion from. Just ask Mssrs McLeish or McCarthy.

That's history. What's for tomorrow?

Mowbray is building a core team which will be supplemented with each window. Players are being watched for next season and beyond. He will make mistakes in the transfer window. He will find bargains. His style of football will continue to prompt debate.

It may look bleak at the moment but it was Mowbray who got the club into this division. The spontaneous and systematic firing of managers over a two-year cycle never helped any club. If he takes them down he deserves a chance to get them back up.

And besides it's a long-held tradition at the Birmingham Mail that football managers depart when the respective reporter for that club is off. I was on annual leave when Megson made his exit and on paternity leave when Robson left.

Looking at my diary right now, I don't seem to have any weeks booked off until June. Nor is the wife pregnant.

So, on that basis, it looks like you're stuck with Mowbray - whether you like it or not.

6 Comments

Dan Nash said:

Fantastic article Chris, I'm a fan of yours and have been for a long time yet this is the best piece you've done yet I reckon. A truly honest insight into what has really been going on at Albion.

I'm so happy to hear that Mowbray is'nt under pressure to save his job. At least Jeremy Peace and the board are seeing sense and backing the best manager I've ever known us have in my lifetime (I'm 22), even if scores of Baggies seem to be turning their backs on him less than a year on from when he led us to our first title win in 88 years and the FA Cup semi final. Mowbray's master plan may not have had an immediate return to the Championship in it but I and I'm sure many others are totally behind it. His favouring of giving youngsters a chance is a breath of fresh air from the Robson days. I hope to see some of the youngsters from the youth academy who hammered Liverpool 4-0 last week integrated into a successful Mowbray led Albion side one day, playing flamboyantly in tune with his well documented footballing philosophies! He was right not to just aim for survival - do that and you set yourself up for a relegation battle no matter what. Aim high or don't aim at all, the philosophy of a winner!

I guess the one criticism of Mowbray has to be, as you say Chris, some of the signings. Valero has been an expensive flop. Mind you, I could see why we bought him when I saw him playing for Mallorca in that pre-season friendly. He was speedy, clever, confident. He doesn't look half that now. We needed replacements for Gera and Phillips in the summer, and we didn't get them. That's not enough of a reason to fire Mowbray though.

I would rather see us go down trying to play to Mowbray's philosophies than sink to the level of Stoke and play woeful football. I could never, ever be proud of that, or waste my money on a season ticket for that sort of football. It's not just Stoke either, Wigan and Bolton are similar, as are a few other teams. If it's got to the point where route one physical football is the only way to survive in the Premiership then English football can only get worse, it will be over-run with big strong athletes, few of which have any skill that is truly needed to win trophies. Football should be entertainment on the field, not business.

In Mowbray I still trust!

Raj said:

Cracking article. Tell Mr Mowbray to keep believing please!

I second that Dan. Im 20 and i still have faith in Mowbray regardless of what this season brings. Some fans have short memories. That's football. I think he has been a breath of fresh air for the Albion. Yet the performance against Fulham didnt inspire confidence..but we still have to believe. And what of Borja? I watched him a number of times in La Liga and he looked a real class act. When i heard we where in for him..i was delighted when we purchased. He will be a decent player given time...but its what this industry doesnt giev anyone. Keep the faith. In regards to radio-phone ins..to me they are people who ring in with knee-jerk reactios after a match has been played. I think the vast majority have faith in Mowbray and the team. Come on you Baggies!!!!

Matthew Kent said:

It is hard to judge how good Valero is without seeing him play with a specialist defensive midfielder.

Wilko said:

I'm not going to shout 'Mowbray Out', but all of this 'short memories' talk is rubbish in my opinion. People keep talking about winning the league last year - we should have WALKED it witht he players we had, and I'm confident we would have been promoted with any of a host of managers in charge because we had the best squad by a long way.

In terms of the FA Cup, people don't seem to remember that we came unstuck against the FIRST top flight team we played in the competition.

Yes it was a fantastic year for us, actually having something to shout about - but for me, it was inevitable, whoever was in charge, that we would walk the league.

This season, Mowbray has got it completely wrong, and has only been helped byt he fact that everyone is beating everyone. No experience, no holding midfielder, no striker - everyone could see that, but nothing was done!

The only positive is that Mowbray IS still learning, and when we bounce back next year, lets hope he's learned his lesson!

Igorbalis said:

Good article Chris.

I hope we don't see people calling for his head, given time he will be a top manager as long as TM does learn from his mistakes. Getting rid of him wouldn't solve anything and only make things worse, at least on our day we play good football compared to Robson's style that had me wanting to stick pins into my eyes.

As others have pointed out Valero hasn't made the impact we all had hoped he would, but some foreigners take time to settle in this league, a new country etc... I think less would have been said about the Valero transfer if we'd brought a defensive midfielder in, this would've helped his game and our leaky defence. For me this above all else has been the most disappointing decision under TM's reign. A typical english type 'ball winner' should've been a priority before the start of last season and even more so for this season. I think we wouldn't be bottom know if we had one. On too many occasions our midfield has been overrun and we've been easily beaten.

If we do go down, i'm glad Peace is running a tight ship, it will allow us to build again and hopefully not go down the route of some other clubs like Leeds, Leicester, Charlton, Southampton etc...

Keep the faith.

Chris Lepkowski said:

Hi Igorbalis,

Thanks for comment. Mowbray has tried to bring in a defensive midfielder since Day One. Kevin Thomson (who was close to joining twice) and others have all been targetted during the last two years. It's always been the one area Albion have failed to fill when deals have come down to the negotiation stage.

Chris

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

This is to help prevent spamming and confirm you are a human

 

Keep up to date

Categories

Sponsored Links