Panic on the streets of Birmingham
Okay, okay, so only one quarter of the Hawthorns lies in the boundary.
But the Smiths could hardly have said 'West Bromwich' as it would have been a lyrical nightmare.
"What's going on down the Albion?", asked a friend on Saturday when I finally got my phone working again.
I can only report what I find.
But clearly there is concern.
Tony Mowbray was fairly honest yesterday (Monday) morning and doing his best to stay upbeat. He talks about the finer details of the Premier League, about how luck has deserted his side and how the competitive nature of this division is keeping Albion in the hunt.
He knows that he needs more quality. That is likely to come in loan form - don't expect big money signings to be arriving any time soon after Big Ben leads us into 2009.
Mowbray takes defeat badly. Saturday wasn't the first occasion I've seen him say things which, with hindsight, he probably regretted afterwards. Bemoaning Stoke's style of play do him little favours when points are dished out.
But on Monday mornings you catch him in a more reflective state. He tries to be positive, which is how he was yesterday.
He is appreciating that Filipe Teixeira opting to shoot rather than pass to Ishmael Miller in front of goal is not a big deal in the Championship. Another chance will come at some point. Not in the Premier League.
Back in the summer Mowbray had a fairly animated chat with my colleague Colin Tattum at a Football Writers' Dinner regarding life in the Premier League. Colin, who witnessed Blues' slide into the Championship, insisted big money would need to be invested. Mowbray argued that he wouldn't need to spend much to survive, that he could 'sprinkle magic dust' over the players and create an overachieving side, much in the way Hull have. But, six months on, Mowbray has said that it was no coincidence that Borja and Zuiverloon were strong performers as they cost decent money. He wanted to achieve another Hibs at Albion and he may still do so - but the gap between the best and the rest in the Premier League is considerably larger than it seems to be in the SPL. He is coming round to the idea that investment is needed to some degree in the top flight. Speculate to accumulate, is what they say isn't it? In Albion's case it needs to be in the wages department.
As for the feeling of fear among fans. That is understandable.
And, one would hope, that Albion's Premier League luck wasn't all used up on that sunny day at The Hawthorns back in 2005 when they stayed up against the odds.
There's no doubt the following factors are all contributing to the 'depression' around the club: the over-achieving Stoke and Hull, Wolves and Blues doing well in the Championship, Villa going strongly, Kevin Phillips scoring, Phillips not being replaced, and teams generally picking up points in unexpected fashion and with a slick of luck (note Hull's equaliser at Portsmouth and the uncanny timing of their games against Newcastle and Spurs when both sides were at their lowest ebb).
It's by no means over for Albion. Tony Mowbray hasn't become a bad manager overnight but he knows those fine margins, which he talks about, are crucial at this level.
He needs backing during transfer windows. Albion have the lowest wage bill at this level. To put into some context, Albion's highest earner only earns half of what James Beattie at Sheffield United takes home. Or, put another way, only half of what ex-Albion man Jason Roberts, probably Blackburn's second/third choice striker, earns at a club that are 19th in the Premier League. It's a commonly held view that the Premier League table reflects the League table of salaries. In which case, can Albion expect much else?
It's a learning curve for Mowbray. Does he stick with his principles? Is this merely a bad patch? Albion were good enough to beat Everton, Bolton, Middlesbrough, West Ham and Fulham earlier this season. They didn't win the first two but, with more luck and barring individual errors, would have done.
The principles can work, yet Albion aren't playing the way they were. My feeling is that Albion's defeat at Stoke was a result of him being too preoccupied with Stoke's style of football and the fear of becoming another Delap statistic. Albion countered both, but at the expense of their own football.
They need to get back to basics. He needs to stop getting bogged down with those who are sniping at him or sneering at him. He will become a better manager through all of this. He'll need to, just to survive and, not least, if he is to fulfill his ambitions. As he rightly points out, Albion were joined on the winners' podium by 'footballing' sides Swansea, MK Dons, Manchester United and, of course, Spain last season. Whether Albion have the players to carry it off playing the same way remains to be seen. One thing's for sure - you can't imagine this set of players being suit for a more pragmatic or direct style.
Back in August and September Albion won games based on their passing football and good movement. There is no reason why they shouldn't again.



Hiya Chris.
Im feeling preety low to be honest with you mate. But as ever i have huge faith in Mowbray. I always will..my faith and believe in him will never waver. I met him at the forum on Thursay and he comes across as a very focused manager who wants the best for Albion. I can feel the passion when he talks. He is a top man. Ultimately football is a and always be a results driven industry. However what ever happens this season i would back him. I cant imagine life without Mowbray at the Albion. I just wish Peace could match his ambition? I dont think he does. Thats the problem.
Did you listen to what he said on MOTD? The extended version? http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/match_of_the_day/7744099.stm
Reading Mowbray is sometimes difficult..i dont know whether he was having a "dig" at Stokes style when he said he tries to improve players day on day. I really feel for Mowbray at the moment. There are certain people in the media who are sneering at him. I read an article by Lou Macari and Stan Collymore( If you would like the links..message me back). Did you hear what Hansen said on MOTD? I dont buy into that. We were good enough to beat West Ham, Fulham and Boro. Whats changed?
Chris, would you say this his biggest challenge since being at The Hawthorns?
In Mowbray We Trust..as always.
A good read, as usual Chris.
For all Mowbray's insistence that he will not sacrifice his footballing principles it seems to most fans that I speak to that he has already abandoned them. That's why the panic has started.
Mowbray is concentrating far too much on nullifying the opposition rather trying to create chances to beat them. He appears fearful of every team that we play. That can only filter through to the players who he has gone on record as saying are not as good as their opponents in nearly every game this season.
We need to return to the dynamic play that we saw in the Championship where the game plan was that we would score more goals than the opposition. Sure against some of the better teams we will take a beating but had we put in a more attacking up tempo display against Everton we would have beaten them.
For the fans to retain belief Mowbray needs to display belief.
The decisions that the Manager has made this season have gone a long way to contributing to our position and whilst there will be fingers pointed at Jeremy Peace for lack of investment the Manager has chosen to go with a squad lacking in experience and ultimately he will have to pay the price or take the plaudits for that.
My dread is that this season will turn in to another great surrender, (ala Robson's relegation season).
For the last two seasons Mowbray has been a breath of fresh air and I would hate to see him lose his job because he has forgotten everything that he did before.
I agree with everything you say Chris,can mowbrays pretty football keep us in this division i don't think so.We do not have the quality players to play the same as arsenal,who play the same style as us but have better players.The style of football we play was alright in the championship,which was proved by us winning the league,but in the premiership you need more skillful players to play the style we do.Stoke and hull play a more direct approach which seams to suit there style of football in this division,so can mowbray turn it round in the new year.As a baggies fan for more than 60years I'm afraid the jury is out,if he buys or loans well in January then we might stay up other wise it looks like all we have to look forward to is another GREAT ESCAPE
Steve, Dave, Anon,
Interesting points from all of you. Thanks for posting.
Dave, please feel free to email me the link to the Collymore piece. And, in answer to your question, yes I do feel this is his biggest challenge. It's going to make promotion from the Championship seem like smallfry by the time this season has run its course. But, like I said in my piece, Albion are owed some luck. You need more, much more, than that to stay up. It would, however, be a start...
Thanks
Chris
Good to read posts from genuine fans that seem
to genuinely know what they're talking about.
Just turned off the radio after hearing some
dipstick that never bothers going to the games
calling TM 'Muppet Mowbray.' I rate Mowbray. The
guy's been a breath of fresh air since arriving
at The Hawthorns & it's up to us die-hards to
get behind him & the team! Chris, you're right,
we do seem to have lost our way a bit. I think
the negativity shown from playing United,Chelsea
& Liverpool, was for some reson still evident
at Stoke, & i can only put that down to the way
Stoke play. Unfortunately, until January, we
have to go with the players we've got & true, we
do have a lot of players(especially midfielders)
that are very 'samey.' Attacking players! Have
faith in em Tony, encourage em to go & attack
like we were against West Ham & Everton & i'm
confident we can get the victories Hull are
getting. Let's be bold! I still believe we'll
stay up, but if we do go down & go down trying
to attack & play entertaining football, i'll
re-new my season ticket again next season!
COME ON YOU BAGGIES!!
In keeping with the blog title, how about 'hang the DJ' ie the manager?
As Mr Pulis so expertly put it, Albion's football = sideways, backwards, sidweways, backwards . . .
Hi Chris et al,
Thanks first of all to Johnny Marr for his incisive comments...let's just see where the 2 sides end up come May, shall we (although let's hope that doesn't return to haunt me in the way TM's similar dig at Sunderland did 2 seasons ago!)
There is definitely a sense of fear spreading around the Brummie Rd each week - almost a fear of the inevitable lapse which will again cost us deserved points. Blackburn is the obvious example, but even against Hull we had done enough to win the game by half time given a fair wind and some half-decent finishing. Should have doesn't win points, however.
All this said, coming back to our Stoke "friend's" comments, I'd sooner be paying my season ticket money to see us play as we are than watching the attritional, one dimensional hoof-ball which Pulis claims as "playing through sides". Give me another rampant season in the Championship any day of the week rather than resort to that to stay afloat among the elite.
Hopefully there are enough like-minded Baggies to keep getting behing Tony and the boys each week, and once again we'll try to "keep the faith" and perhaps enjoy seeing the smug Hansen's & Collymore's being forced to give us at least a little credit should we manage to pull it off. 3 points at Wigan wouldn't be the worst start to kick things off! Go for it boys, and we "shall not want" for goals in the long run...
Hiya Chris. Just read your message now. Thanks for your reply. Here is the link to the Stan Collymore piece:
http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/columnists/collymore/2008/11/24/west-brom-need-to-abandon-footballing-principles-to-stay-in-the-premier-league-115875-20920256/
In reading it..i dont believe in what he says. As you cant just play ugly and then sinmply change your style. Look at Sunderland they spent upwards of £50 million and only TWO players from that team started against West Ham. ( One being Dean Whitehead who has been a mainstay for a number of years). Then in the summer they spent another £50 million, yet to me they remind me of a West Brom under Robson, but with better individuals. Mowbray atleast is trying to create a culture rather then just being another run of the mill football club.
Must be painful to lose to a pub side like Stoke, but only to be expected when El Mowbray plays just one up front I suppose. What happened to the idea of Barcelona-style football?
Do you think Wolves will do any better when they take your place in the Prem?
Good right up chris
Ive stayed away from comenting this week. Poeple need to remmember where we were before last seson. Its only 6 months since we won the legue. now poeple want him out!