Stewart Downing: From zero to hero and back again

By Mat Kendrick, Aston Villa correspondent
SOMEWHERE on Stewart Downing's mantelpiece is a metal pin in a glass jar.
Villa fans understandably fuming from Downing's impending departure to Liverpool could be excused for thinking it's a Frankenstein-style bolt from the winger's neck, given the general claret and blue consensus that the club created a monster.
In actual fact the steel pin is the one which bonded his fractured foot with sufficient success he passed a medical on crutches at Villa exactly two years ago on Saturday.
Downing kept it as a souvenir of the faith Villa showed in signing him for a then joint club record £12 million fee from relegated Middlesbrough despite his serious injury woes.
"It was quite a long pin to be fair," Downing told me back in October 2009.
"Am I keeping the pin? Yeah, but I have had to have it sterilised.
"I am keeping it. It just looks like a nail you would bang into a door."
He might as well bang it into the Anfield dressing room wall to hang his new Reds shirt, although Villa fans would gladly string him up on it given half a chance.
It's not so much the leaving for bigger and better things, although quitting for another club without European football next season is a slight on the claret and blues.
It's more the leading on and letting down; the tacit refusal to acknowledge and repay the privilege Randy Lerner gave him by subsidising his half a season on a treatment table without kicking a ball.
It's that Downing was happy to take Villa's money when few other top clubs would have touched him, but that any loyalty was conspicuous by its absence as soon as the first head-turning sniff of an offer materialised.
Then there was the shoddy way his departure was engineered.
First he dropped his shoulder and took all the Villa fans with him by declaring he would be open to the idea of signing a new contract.
Then he dropped his other shoulder and sent supporters the other way by not only stalling on the deal, but strongly hinting he would not be a Villa player next season.
I was lucky enough to get an exclusive interview with Downing at Villa's annual awards dinner on May 9 when he picked up the fans', players' and sponsors' best player gongs.
This was his position back then: "I think there's been a couple of conversations already with my agent. I've already spoken to the manager who has said he'd like to keep me.
"I'm enjoying my stay here. I've enjoyed it since the first day I came. It's a terrific football club. It's fantastic they want me.
"There's terrific players. I'm confident, despite this season, we're going in the right direction and if we get the right players in then I'm happy.

"The important thing in football is, if you're happy, then why change it?
"I know it's been a disappointing season, but I can see the bigger picture."
By May 26, in an interview given to a newspaper in his native north east, the 'bigger picture' was becoming blurred.
"I am 26 and at a major crossroads in my career so I won't be committing to a new deal at the moment."
A month later on June 30, on England duty ahead of the Euro 2012 qualifying draw with Switzerland, Downing was now freezing Villa out of the 'bigger picture' completely by discussing how fans would react to his likely departure.
"You hope they do understand, but normal fans will want you to stay at their club for the rest of your life.
"If you do leave there's obviously a bit of bitterness there.
"You hope they do understand because, it's like any job, if there's a better job on hand, or a better level to do it, then people do it."
It was particularly galling as Downing had always seemed like one of the good guys. As far removed from the mercenary money-grabbing monster as you could possibly imagine.
From the first occasion I met him - chatting to him on the ground floor of Bodymoor Heath to save him struggling up the stairs on crutches - he struck me as a decent lad.
He went up even further in my estimation when discussing the emotive subject of the death of a sibling months later.
Luke Young was nearing a return to action after his half brother Andre tragically passed away during a holiday accident and Young's close pal and former Boro team-mate Downing spoke with real empathy, having lost his own baby sister Vicki to leukemia years earlier.
Stew would always be the one prepared to face the press, win lose or draw after matches, and I can recall him, in Anfield of all places, huddled in a cubbyhole, honestly explaining Villa's dreadful 3-0 defeat to Liverpool last December and patiently answering increasingly probing questions where other players would have excused themselves and left.
On the face of it, £20 million at this given time, seems a fair price with the chance the England winger could struggle to eclipse his fine personal form of last season.
I could be wrong and he could blossom with Liverpool, the club his father purports to support, apparently.
Either way his value would obviously decrease 12 months from now if he entered the final year of his contract at Villa and the extra time to recruit a replacement is probably more important to Alex McLeish that the extra few million pounds he could have potentially held out for.
Fortunately for Downing, Kenny Dalglish's willingness to pay the going rate has spared him running the gauntlet of hate at Walsall, which Gareth Barry was subjected to three summers ago.
And remember, Barry, who didn't get his move to Merseyside, boasted a decade's loyal service, rather than one special season and half a steady one.
Instead of next Thursday's pre-season friendly at the Banks's Stadium, Downing will have to wait until Saturday December 17, when Liverpool visit Villa Park in the Premier League, to find out first hand precisely what the claret and blue faithful think of him.
No need to bring the pin, Stewart, there's guaranteed to be plenty of needle.
Older/Newer
« New banner unfurled on the Holte End | Aston Villa: Jean Makoun won't be pushed despite Olympiakos rumours »



downing has gone now he is a trater now mclish needs to get someone toreplace him :) gurry up we need to be hiting the top 6 next season i am a holte end lower season icket holder and i would like to see some good football xx
Brilliant blog Mat, summed up my feelings on the situation. Your timeline of Stewie's comments certainly give food for thought, was he tapped up? I suppose it doesn't matter now, we made £8million on him and hopefully the £20million fee will be reinvested in two or three new players. UTV
Brilliant blog Mat, summed up my feelings on the situation. Your timeline of Stewie's comments certainly give food for thought, was he tapped up? I suppose it doesn't matter now, we made £8million on him and hopefully the £20million fee will be reinvested in two or three new players. UTV
I think the time has come for fans to realise that modern day footballers care little for the teams they play for, a lesson we need to learn or be constantly left with an empty feeling inside when every transfer window comes by. Do i wish Downing stayed, to be honest no.....he was decent last season but to be honest to get 20 million for him was almost robbery and the scousers should call the police. Very average player... the fact is within 2 years Albrighton will put Downing in the shade.....Downing is by defination mr average.
20 mil is far too much. Good business by city I think. I think it's important to note that Downing did say:
"if we get the right players in then I'm happy"
Surely his mate Ashley Young moving on didn't help. I'm a Liverpool supporter but tend to think Man U got the better player at a better price.
20 mil is far too much. Good business by Villa I think. I think it's important to note that Downing did say:
"if we get the right players in then I'm happy"
Surely his mate Ashley Young moving on didn't help. I'm a Liverpool supporter but tend to think Man U got the better player at a better price.